Published on
- 9 min read
Nutrition Showdown: Ranking the Best Plant-Based Milks
Which plant-based milk deserves that prime spot in your fridge? Let’s rank the best by their nutritional punch.
Nutrition Showdown: Ranking the Best Plant-Based Milks
Plant-based milks now crowd the shelves like never before. From vegan cafes to family kitchens, options like oat milk, almond milk, and soy milk are everywhere. But when it comes to your health and nutrition, which nondairy milk really delivers? Here, we sort through the hype and break down the best plant-based milks, ranked by their nutritional value, ingredients, and benefits—helping you choose the right blend for your needs and lifestyle.
Why Plant-Based Milks?
Non-dairy milks—often called plant-based milks or vegan milks—are made from nuts, seeds, grains, or legumes. People flock to them not only for ethical or allergy reasons, but also for their environmental benefits, their compatibility with lactose free diets, and their impressive array of flavors.
But not all plant milks are created equal. Some are loaded with nutrients, while others are mostly water with a handful of almonds. Knowing the nutritional profiles, fortification practices, and common additives is key to making an informed, healthy choice at the grocery store.
What to Look For: Key Nutritional Metrics
When deciding on the best plant-based milk, here’s what matters most:
- Protein: Critical for muscle maintenance and satiety.
- Calcium and Vitamin D: These are often added during fortification to match or exceed dairy milk levels.
- B Vitamins and Vitamin A: Contribute to immunity, energy, and cellular health.
- Healthy Fats: Shape heart health and keep you full.
- Sugar Content: Many flavored versions hide surprising amounts of added sugar.
- Additives: Emulsifiers, gums, and fortifying minerals and vitamins.
For this ranking, unsweetened and fortified versions are evaluated, as these represent the healthiest and most comparable alternatives to cow’s milk.
The Best Plant-Based Milks Ranked by Nutrition
Let’s break down the most popular options, highlighting pros, cons, key statistics, and who each milk best serves.
1. Soy Milk
Soy milk is consistently regarded as the gold standard in plant-based milks, nutritionally speaking. Why?
Nutritional Highlights:
- Protein: 7-9g per cup (comparable to dairy milk)
- Calcium: Usually fortified to 25-30% Daily Value (DV)
- Vitamin D: Typically 15-20% DV
- Iron, B12, and Vitamin A: Frequently added
Benefits:
- Complete protein source (contains all essential amino acids)
- Isoflavones that may promote heart health
- Unsweetened versions very low in sugar
Downsides:
- Not suitable for those with soy allergies
- Sometimes a “beany” aftertaste
Who Should Drink It?
- Anyone seeking protein equivalent to cow’s milk (great for growing children, teenagers, athletes, and vegans)
Tip: Always check for “non-GMO” and “fortified” labeling if those are priorities.
2. Pea Milk
A relative newcomer, pea milk, usually made from yellow peas, has quickly risen in popularity—thanks largely to its protein power and allergy-friendly status.
Nutritional Highlights:
- Protein: 8g per cup
- Calcium: Fortified to 30-45% DV
- Potassium: Nearly double the amount in cow’s milk
Benefits:
- Neutral taste, creamy texture
- Free of nuts, soy, gluten, and lactose
- Environmentally less taxing than almond or dairy
Downsides:
- Not universally available
- Can be pricier than other options
Who Should Drink It?
- People with soy/nut allergies or wanting high protein without soy
3. Hemp Milk
Hemp milk is a powerhouse of omega-3 and omega-6 fatty acids—the stuff heart health enthusiasts crave.
Nutritional Highlights:
- Protein: 3g per cup
- Omega-3 and 6: High amounts per serving
- Calcium: Fortified to 20-30% DV
Benefits:
- Offers iron, magnesium, and a little zinc
- Strong choice for anti-inflammatory benefits
- Nutty flavor that blends nicely in smoothies
Downsides:
- Lower in protein than soy or pea milk
- Can separate over time; stir before use
Who Should Drink It?
- Those who want plant-based omega-3s without nuts and enjoy a mild, earthy flavor
4. Oat Milk
Oat milk shot to fame for its creamy richness and coffee-friendliness, but how does it stack up nutritionally?
Nutritional Highlights:
- Protein: 2-4g per cup
- Fiber: About 2g, provides beta-glucans found in whole oats
- Calcium & Vitamin D: Fortified to match dairy
- Vitamin B12: Often added
Benefits:
- Great taste and texture for lattes and baking
- Oats are gluten-free (watch for processing contamination though)
- May lower cholesterol (thanks to beta-glucans)
Downsides:
- Higher in carbs (~16g per cup)
- Can spike blood sugar if heavily processed; opt for whole oat varieties
Who Should Drink It?
- Those seeking a balanced, creamy milk for everyday use, especially in coffee and cereal
5. Almond Milk
Almond milk is probably the most popular plant-based milk in U.S. grocery stores. Its light flavor makes it endlessly versatile.
Nutritional Highlights:
- Protein: 1g per cup
- Calcium: Fortified to 25-40% DV
- Vitamin E: High, naturally present
- Typically low in calories (30-50 kcal unsweetened)
Benefits:
- Excellent for low-calorie diets
- Good source of vitamin E (antioxidant)
- Mild and versatile
Downsides:
- Low in protein
- Environmental concerns over water use
- Many brands contain thickeners and stabilizers
Who Should Drink It?
- Calorie counters, or those using milk for smoothies, baking, or as a splash in coffee or tea
6. Flax Milk
Flax milk flies under the radar, but it’s a fantastic source of plant-based omega-3s, especially if you can’t have nuts or soy.
Nutritional Highlights:
- Protein: 0-3g per cup, depending on fortification
- Omega-3: Highest among plant milks
- Calcium & Vitamin D: Fortified to 20-30% DV
Benefits:
- Excellent nut-free and soy-free alternative
- Mild, easy-to-blend flavor
Downsides:
- Low protein unless specifically enriched
- Can taste thin and watery if unsweetened
Who Should Drink It?
- Those seeking omega-3s with allergies to soy, nuts, or gluten
7. Coconut Milk (Carton)
Note: The refrigerated or shelf-stable carton variety is different from canned coconut milk used for cooking.
Nutritional Highlights:
- Protein: <1g per cup
- High in saturated fat (compared to others)
- Fortified with calcium and vitamin D
Benefits:
- Works well for flavoring tropical smoothies or desserts
- Naturally sweet, some say the best flavor for rice pudding
Downsides:
- Practically no protein
- Somewhat higher in calories, primarily from fats
Who Should Drink It?
- Coconut lovers, or those needing a nut-free/gluten-free/soy-free option for occasional use
8. Rice Milk
Rice milk is hypoallergenic and naturally sweet.
Nutritional Highlights:
- Protein: <1g per cup
- Carbohydrate: Highest among all plant milks (~22g per cup)
- Calcium & Vitamin D: Fortified
Benefits:
- Best choice for those with multiple allergies
- Mild, unobtrusive taste perfect for drinking straight
Downsides:
- High glycemic index—can spike blood sugar quickly
- Not suitable for children or those requiring higher protein
Who Should Drink It?
- Allergy sufferers, and those who want a very neutral milk for drinking by the glass
9. Cashew Milk
Creamy and a rising star in the world of barista-style plant milks.
Nutritional Highlights:
- Protein: 1g per cup
- Low calorie, often just 25-40 kcal per cup
- Fortified with calcium and vitamin D
Benefits:
- Silky texture for lattes and soups
- Mild taste, blends into sweet or savory recipes
Downsides:
- Low protein content
- May contain gums and emulsifiers
Who Should Drink It?
- Low-calorie seekers, and those looking for a blendable, mild-tasting milk
Photo by Jakub Żerdzicki on Unsplash
10. Macadamia Milk
A luxurious choice with a hint of buttery flavor.
Nutritional Highlights:
- Protein: <1g per cup
- Healthy monounsaturated fats
- Often fortified with calcium and vitamin D
Benefits:
- Deliciously creamy (great for specialty coffee drinks)
- Subtle, natural sweetness
Downsides:
- Lower in protein
- Can be more expensive
- Watch for added sweeteners
Who Should Drink It?
- Those wanting a “treat” base for coffee or recipes, rather than a daily staple
Specialized Blends and Fortified Milks
Some brands are now making high-protein or “superfood” blends, combining protein-rich options with added nutrients like DHA (from algae), extra fiber, or vitamins B12 and D2. These options are ideal if your dietary needs require extra boost or if you follow a strict vegan diet. Always read the label since some of these blends can also add sugar or gums to modify texture.
Reading Labels: Beware the Sweetener Trap
Just like with dairy milk, flavored and sweetened versions of plant-based milks are everywhere. Some have as much added sugar as a can of soda. If gut health, diabetes risk, or weight management are considerations, always choose unsweetened varieties.
Common sweeteners include:
- Cane sugar
- Agave syrup
- Brown rice syrup
Caramel coloring and “natural flavors” are also often added. Those with food sensitivity or allergies, be alert.
Fortification: Not All Plant Milks Are Equal
Unlike cow’s milk, which is naturally rich in nutrients, most plant milks must be fortified to offer comparable calcium, vitamin D, and B12 levels. Fortification policies vary by country and by brand. Look for these nutrients in the ingredient list or nutrition facts panel, and pick a brand that reliably fortifies.
How to Choose The Right Plant-Based Milk For You
Ultimately, which plant-based milk is “best” depends on your needs:
- For protein: Soy milk or pea milk
- For low calories: Almond milk or cashew milk
- For heart-healthy fats: Hemp milk or flax milk
- For allergy sufferers: Rice milk or flax milk
- For foaming or frothing: Oat milk or macadamia milk
- For a children’s diet: Soy milk (due to its full amino acid profile and protein content)
Common Myths About Plant-Based Milks
“Plant Milk Has No Protein”
Not true—options like soy and pea milk offer a protein punch close to or even better than dairy.
“They Aren’t as Nutritious as Cow’s Milk”
Many are, especially if fortified. Some, like almond and rice, offer fewer calories or sugar than even skim cow’s milk.
“All Plant Milks Are Gluten-Free”
Look out: while oats are naturally gluten-free, cross-contamination is common, so always check labeling if celiac or sensitive.
Environmental Impact: A Quick Note
If you’re switching for the planet, plant-based milks generally have a lower carbon footprint than dairy. Almond milk gets flak for water usage, but it still typically requires less water and land, and has lower emissions, than producing cow’s milk. Oat, hemp, pea and flax milks get high marks for being particularly eco-friendly. Sustainability, though, depends on sourcing, production method, and packaging—so pick from companies with transparent practices.
DIY Plant-Based Milks: Worth the Effort?
Homemade plant milks, like almond, cashew, or oat milk, are easy to make and have the advantage of being free from unwanted additives or gum. But note—these milks will not be fortified, so they may lack crucial vitamins and calcium unless you add them yourself. Homemade blends also have a shorter shelf life (usually just a few days) and may have a coarser texture.
The Verdict: The Best Overall
If you’re looking for one top tier, all-around plant-based milk:
- Soy milk (unsweetened, fortified) gives the best balance of protein, calcium, vitamins, and overall nutrition.
- Pea milk is a runner-up, great for those who want soy-free, high-protein, allergen-friendly choices.
- For coffee, oat milk rules, but save it for those lattes rather than full-time nutrition.
The key to getting the best from plant-based milks is finding the right fit for your preferences and health needs, always reading labels, and opting for unsweetened, fortified versions wherever possible.
Final Tips for A Healthy Plant Milk Habit
- Rotate milks for nutritional variety.
- Prioritize fortified, unsweetened types.
- Check protein and calcium stats if these nutrients matter in your diet.
- For toddlers and young kids, consult with your pediatrician before making a big switch.
The plant milk universe is vast and growing. By understanding the strengths and weaknesses of each option, you can happily—and healthily—ditch the dairy without missing a beat.
External Links
The 11 Healthiest Milks and Plant-Based Alternatives Plant Milks Ranked From Best to Worst: See How Your Favorite Fared Every Plant Milk on the Planet, Ranked - livekindly The 7 Healthiest Milk Options - Healthline Milks Ranked - Nutrition Tier Lists - YouTube